/v/lancer strikes again?

Honestly, given that you’re from /b/, I didn’t expect anything less.
Also, LOLOLOL I TROL U.

Anubis wrote:
I’m not claiming you ever took anything from me. I’m arguing because, well, I’m better than you. And here’s why:

I don’t think that means what you think it means.

“Joke’s on them, I was only pretending to be retarded”

Not only am I from /b/, I’m in American Politics. There are no greater trolls known to man, except for maybe The Right Honourable Nick Clegg.

But, in any case, there is no reason for this thread to continue. It’s just trolls trolling trolls for no good reason. You don’t like us, we don’t like you. We came to that conclusion a while ago.

Implying you were actually trolling and not just trying to cover up your retarded mistake.

Skeletor wrote:
I hereby request you submit legally documented proof of your copyright on said models that you do not want in /v/lancer. They must be signed and dated BEFORE they were ever uploaded to the internet, or else they become fair use. You can’t upload something, then months later apply for a copyright, and have it be valid.

**Not sure what school of legal idiocy you got that from but that’s totally incorrect. In the great scheme of things it doesn’t matter anyway. Shows how clever you guys are anyway by quoting the EULA as well saying nothing can be modified. This isn’t true either if you could be bothered to keep up with current events and Microsofts standing towards game modification…

The simple truth here and i’ll type s l o w l y so it sinks in, is this. Anyone creates a custom anything, be that model/music/image not originally from FL has the legal copyright to said artifact, end of.
If that person chooses to share it on the web, that’s fine but credit should be given, preferably asked for, in the case of commercialy available music for instance, definately need permission. If said article is then used without permission then a legal issue arises. Simple enough for you?**

Bold text does not make you correct.

Green text does.

Gibbon wrote:

Skeletor wrote:
I hereby request you submit legally documented proof of your copyright on said models that you do not want in /v/lancer. They must be signed and dated BEFORE they were ever uploaded to the internet, or else they become fair use. You can’t upload something, then months later apply for a copyright, and have it be valid.

**Not sure what school of legal idiocy you got that from but that’s totally incorrect. In the great scheme of things it doesn’t matter anyway. Shows how clever you guys are anyway by quoting the EULA as well saying nothing can be modified. This isn’t true either if you could be bothered to keep up with current events and Microsofts standing towards game modification…

The simple truth here and i’ll type s l o w l y so it sinks in, is this. Anyone creates a custom anything, be that model/music/image not originally from FL has the legal copyright to said artifact, end of.
If that person chooses to share it on the web, that’s fine but credit should be given, preferably asked for, in the case of commercialy available music for instance, definately need permission. If said article is then used without permission then a legal issue arises. Simple enough for you?**

That is neither factually nor legally accurate. A copyright is government paperwork that has to be both completed and filed before it can be accepted and/or legally protected. Nothing is ever “automatically copyrighted” because you say it is. Just because you say “ORIJINUL KARAKTURR DO NOT STEEL” does not make it a legally protected copyright.

Unless you can provide documentation (ALL copyrighted works have documentation, or they are not, in fact, copyrighted) proving your claim, fair use still stands, and if you CAN provide documentation, it must have been dated and confirmed before the date it was first put on the internet.

The simple truth here and i’ll type s l o w l y so it sinks in, is this. Anyone creates a custom anything, be that model/music/image not originally from FL has the legal copyright to said artifact, end of.

Not as a mod broski.
Again, Berne Convention.

Not a point here that’s worth arguing about, little boys.

Here’s the bottom line: does anyone here who is offended have the money to go to court?

All we have said from the beginning in many other threads is:

1. Nobody has the right to refuse permission to use something if they made it available (without locks or encryption that need to be defeated).

2. It’s a matter of pure courtesy to ask for permission and not use if it is denied.

That’s all, little children.

'bye.

Haven’t read all posts yet, plus I am at school so excuse me if my points got answered álready later on.

Anyone who makes models for freelancer, then distributes them to the community via mods, and then complains when other modders use them in their own mods is a bit hypocritical. You can’t put something up for free on the internet and complain when people use it. You can’t steal anything that is free

That’s actually TOTALLY wrong. Take a free software like the VM Player as an example (I hope I didn’t miss-choose again ^), just because it doesn’t cost anything it doesn’t mean that you are free to use it and even alter and re-distribute it like you are going to. DEFINITIVLY NOT.
Also, in terms it is a HUGE difference between using a software and re-distributing it. And we both know what /v/lancer did, don’t we?
You mostly just get the servitude for the most software, not the copyright.

Skeletor speaks the truth. None of the so-called “stolen” content can be legally copyrighted, as it is a modification, not an original IP.

IP stands for?

Also, the content CAN be copyrighted. A few examples…first off it might be important if the modifications are trivial or not. INI-Coding might not be trivial but audio, for instance, is. Music, sound effects, movies, models - They all CAN be copyrighted. There is no reason why they shouldn’t. They aren’t even limited to the use of Freelancer.

Another point is, for instance, if a mod uses copyrighted content for which the autors might got the permission. This doesn’t mean that actually YOU got the license as well.

Plus, if a mod uses copyrighted ressources illegally it doesn’t make it legal for you to use it then.

I also find it funny how everything here is always belonging to one person and one person alone. I’ve never seen that in any other modding community.

Says something about the modders in the FL Community.

Well, first off, there is a huge difference between MP and SP modding communities since MP modding scenes are in a harder competition.
Plus, I am sure, MANY would have offered ressources if you asked them, maybe they would wanted something in return (your ressources, for instance), maybe not.

However, independent of how cooperative the FL modders might be, they still have the right - in a moralic way - to decide about their work. They have created it, shouldn’t they be the one who decide about what do they want to do with it?

I’m sorry but no. I fully expect to be banned for this post, but it will be worth it entirely.

As I know the administration I highly doubt you will get banned for expressing your opinion as long as you stay polite. Maybe you guys should think about this point as well, you think we are such a bad community but actually let you express your opinion at this plattform, don’t we?

So you might should consider to re-pay this respect to us in the same way.

First, I suggest you look up the term Fair Use, and pull your head out of your ass.

Second of all, your statement has no legal backing whatsoever. Not to mention that there is no such thing as a “Gentlemen’s Agreement” That is just blatantly the most retarded thing I have ever heard. I for one, am glad we can’t advertise /v/lancer on this site, because everyone here is babbies. Real men don’t whine about ONNOEHEUSEDMYMODELTOMAKEAGAMEFUNFOREVERYONE. They sit the #$%% down and have fun with bros. This is why /v/lancer will forever be funner then SWWT and PURPLE. It’s made by bros, for bros.

First off, see above.
Second, W0dk4 never stated that the Gentlemen’s Agreement has any legally power. But if you read my whole posting you might see that ressources can be copyrighted, though, it depends on the content.
Another exaple: Normally a picture whcih you created with, for isntance, GIMP is your work and you hold the copyright. Now, tell me one reason why you should loose your copyright once you include it into one modification?
Also, I remember that you guys said that you want to create the modification for yourself and your “bros” - This simple does mean that your mod isn’t for anyone. So stop advert it that way.
And please don’t make statements about what real men are. This is for what biologists are for.

I hereby request you submit legally documented proof of your copyright on said models that you do not want in /v/lancer. They must be signed and dated BEFORE they were ever uploaded to the internet, or else they become fair use. You can’t upload something, then months later apply for a copyright, and have it be valid.

Totally wrong. you actually HOLD the copyright when you CREATE that object. Thus, if you upload it to the net, even if you don’t include a license, you still HAVE a copyright over it. Just because you decide later to switch to a license it doesn’t mean that your work isn’t protect before that action.
You simple assume that a person doesn’t has any copyright over his work if he doesn’t use a license which is definitivly wrong.

Could you guys please stop this discussion? Just because you tell them that the things they do are illegal/not wanted/whatever… they wont stop doing it…

I agree, simply stop discussing with them. Its clearly trolling and I’d rather not have a constant flame war going on.

Not to mention that we can not keep up with their large community and the hundrets of players playing /V/lancer.
Dont mess with them… they are better, guess that why they dont need to advertise their mod anywhere else.

Well, no, this discussion might become quite useful for the future of FL modding. may i remind our fair gentlemen of early times, on MD’s Rebalance mod? it was mostly a constellation of contents from other mods whether credited or not, whether with permissions or not. however, although for most models/images/whatever we do, we have a legal copyright, just because we wrote it with our fingers, yes even for most unique codes we hold copyrights (and it is irrelevant whether we have a legal declaration of our rights, you do not need a copy of the constitution to have the right for a happy life - yes, i know, this example is bullshit, but you get the idea i mean), we are neither in position financially or socially to go to the courth and claim for our rights, nor we wish to do so, because its simply not worth it. on the other hand, most of the artists over at our’s only would be glad to see their models in multiple mods. i can not model but there was no modeler yet, who denied me to use his models for my incommercial freelancer project to use for joy of the player community. one even liked the interface of the game and is happy to know i work with his mesh.
noone cares, most not even recognise, if you use their models, sounds, images, videos, whatever you’d like to see in your mod. but once you call it your work, once you try to make innocent players think you have paid time and mental power to create something they like although you havent, no artist will be happy about it. he’d share the model, if you asked, he’d even share, if you do not ask, but if you call it your own, you break the law on the one hand and on the other hand you just handle ungently and honourless. please, at least, credit the artists. i think this is the only thing they want of you, not hunting your mod down, not your community. they just want to keep their names up and they defend their rights. it might work aggressively, sometimes, but the idea behind it is simple and kind.
please, do all of us a service and stop giving us reasons to dislike the months you paid in putting our artists’ stuff together. we don’t want to damage your work’s name. so, help us to get rid of the necessity.

@Mindhunter wow true irony respect
This guys also need to carefully read the meaning of the word “unique” in the Oxford Dictionary :)))

I just had this happened with the saarlancer fools, raiding my mod and telling players ingame they made the starsphere and ships etc etc they have stollen.
But still with my content (beside the stuff from WTS NSU etc) they can NOT keep up with one of those mods.

How will u be on top of u only copy content from others?
While doing that u will always be one step behind!

How will u be on top of u only copy content from others?
While doing that u will always be one step behind!

Sorry, but nobody really cares about your magical server ranking competitions, save for you delightful human beings.

HeIIoween wrote:
@Mindhunter wow true irony respect
This guys also need to carefully read the meaning of the word “unique” in the Oxford Dictionary :)))

You need to look up the word “original” as well, I would imagine. All of your precious mods likely count as Derivative Works, and without demonstrating a substantial amount of original content they can’t by copyrighted. I haven’t seen a single mod that actually includes content (except for /v/lancer) that isn’t directly copied from another IP or includes trademarks built upon those IPs, so. The same goes for models that were made for the mod, I would think.

Also, the ironic thing about all of this is that the entire reason this mod started was because we asked for permission to run a private server of another, and were refused for no real reason at all.

x) No one here has trouble with credits except subj so no.
Inability to agree only yours problem and it is no reason to steal content

Mods as a whole can count as Derivative Work. Individual components however, do not. I make a model. I let someone use it. They use it in a, say, Gundam Mod. The Gundam Mod is a Derivative Work of the Gundam Universe. My model still holds individual copyright. It’s simple.